International experts convened for Exercise Polaris, a simulation addressing the potential emergence of ancient pathogens due to climate change, focusing on the fictional virus Mammothpox.
International experts convened recently for a training exercise, dubbed Exercise Polaris, organised by the World Health Organisation (WHO). This event took place amidst growing concerns about the potential emergence of pathogens from ancient frozen animals, specifically highlighting a fictional virus named ‘Mammothpox’ arising from the carcass of a frozen mammoth. The exercise involved participants from 15 countries who were tasked with simulating the containment of this fictional outbreak.
The scenario imagined that a team of scientists and a film crew, who discovered the frozen mammoth, became infected by this deadly virus, which is conceptually akin to smallpox and closely related to monkeypox, also known as mpox. The mortality rate of Mammothpox was designed to reflect the serious nature of such pathogens, as is the case with smallpox, which had a historical mortality rate of approximately 30% before its eradication in 1980. The potential for this new virus to spread globally was a central concern during the two-day exercise.
Dr Khaled Abass, an environmental health sciences expert from the University of Sharjah in the UAE and co-author of a related study, emphasised the real dangers posed by climate change in releasing ancient parasites and microbes trapped in permafrost. “Climate change is not only melting ice—it’s melting the barriers between ecosystems, animals, and people,” he stated, as reported by the Daily Mail. This further underscores the seriousness of the matter, where previously dormant pathogens may pose new threats of zoonotic diseases capable of jumping from ancient animals to contemporary species, including humans.
The WHO documentation associated with Exercise Polaris elucidated the significant risks of viral re-emergence due to thawing permafrost. The concern stems from previous scientific findings indicating that ancient viruses can remain viable in permafrost for millennia. The exercise was not only an academic simulation; it reflected increasing worries, as noted by various scientists, that as the planet warms, the opportunity for these ancient pathogens to surface grows.
Among the nations involved in this training were representatives from Denmark, Somalia, Qatar, Germany, Saudi Arabia, and Ukraine. Each country was given distinct information about their respective outbreak scenarios, which aimed to evaluate their collaboration and information sharing during a crisis. Scenarios included situations such as an outbreak on a cruise vessel or within confined groups, revealing the varied strategies nations may adopt to control disease spread.
The exercise also highlighted the potential complications of international cooperation in real-life situations, citing current events where countries have opted for divergent health strategies, such as border closures or lockdowns. Participants underlined the challenges posed by political factors, stating these could hinder a unified response during a pandemic.
In the Arctic, the risks are amplified due to limited health monitoring services, which can complicate the identification and containment of zoonotic diseases. Research has indicated that pathogens like Toxoplasma gondii are already spreading in the region, contributing to an increasingly complex health landscape.
In addition to Mammothpox, Exercise Polaris briefly outlined other potential ‘zombie viruses’ that could emerge from permafrost. These include strains of influenza, and various viruses such as Pithovirus sibericum, revived from 30,000-year-old samples, and pathogens found in wool from frozen mammoths. The Arctic environment, now becoming more accessible due to thawing ice, poses further risks as scientists and poachers alike seek ancient animals preserved in ice, with ramifications for both scientific research and biodiversity.
Over the last decade, research has demonstrated the historic viability of viruses stored in the Arctic, confirming incidents where anthrax spores were released from permafrost in 2016, causing hospitalisations and fatalities. Such occurrences stress the need for preparedness in the face of climate-induced changes that could unlock ancient diseases.
The exercise concluded with the realisation that while containment of an outbreak like Mammothpox could theoretically be achievable, actual scenarios would likely present a multitude of unpredictable challenges that require robust international coordination and cooperation.
Source: Noah Wire Services
- https://www.telegraph.co.uk/global-health/science-and-disease/mammoth-pox-pandemic-response-world-health-organization/ – This article provides details about Exercise Polaris, a WHO-led pandemic response simulation that involved a fictional ‘Mammothpox’ outbreak. It explains how the scenario simulated the spread of a virus akin to smallpox and mpox, highlighting the potential risks of ancient pathogens emerging from thawing permafrost.
- http://www.iflscience.com/exercise-polaris-the-who-just-ran-a-2-day-pandemic-preparedness-exercise-78708 – This article discusses Exercise Polaris as a two-day pandemic preparedness exercise conducted by the WHO. It emphasizes the importance of global coordination in responding to health emergencies and notes the participation of multiple countries and health agencies.
- https://www.instagram.com/telegraph/reel/DId_kTKh06z/ – This Instagram reel from The Telegraph highlights the risks associated with ancient viruses preserved in frozen soil that could emerge as the Arctic melts, supporting concerns raised during Exercise Polaris.
- https://www.rt.com/news/615794-who-exercise-mammothpox-outbreak/ – This article reports on Exercise Polaris, describing it as a WHO rehearsal for a deadly ‘Mammothpox’ outbreak. It mentions the virus’s similarity to smallpox and the potential for global spread.
- https://www.noahwire.com/ – This source provides background information on Exercise Polaris, including details about the countries involved and the scenario of a ‘Mammothpox’ outbreak emerging from thawing permafrost.
Noah Fact Check Pro
The draft above was created using the information available at the time the story first
emerged. We’ve since applied our fact-checking process to the final narrative, based on the criteria listed
below. The results are intended to help you assess the credibility of the piece and highlight any areas that may
warrant further investigation.
Freshness check
Score:
8
Notes:
The narrative references recent concerns and a training exercise involving international experts, indicating it is current. However, specific events or breakthroughs could be outdated without further updates.
Quotes check
Score:
6
Notes:
The quote from Dr Khaled Abass is mentioned, but without an earliest known reference online, it is difficult to verify its original source. This could be the first mention of the quote, which suggests it might be original.
Source reliability
Score:
7
Notes:
The narrative originates from the Daily Mail, which is a well-known publication but may have varying levels of credibility on specific topics. Reputable sources like the WHO are referenced but not directly quoted.
Plausability check
Score:
9
Notes:
The claims regarding ‘Mammothpox’ and ancient pathogens emerging due to climate change are plausible and align with scientific concerns about thawing permafrost.
Overall assessment
Verdict (FAIL, OPEN, PASS): OPEN
Confidence (LOW, MEDIUM, HIGH): MEDIUM
Summary:
While the narrative is plausible and recent, concerns about ‘Mammothpox’ involve hypothetical scenarios, and quotes lack verification. The source reliability is moderate due to the publication used.