The Royal Ballet School has ignited a fervent debate surrounding body inclusivity in dance, particularly through its recent initiative to welcome plus-size dancers and same-gender pairings. The move comes on the heels of a highly publicised body-shaming scandal that has thrust the school’s past treatment of its students into the spotlight. While some herald the initiative as a progressive step toward broader representation in ballet, others view it as a potentially damaging shift for the art form.

In his first interview since taking the helm as artistic director, Iain Mackay articulated the school’s vision for a more inclusive future. He stated, “Audiences want dancers they can relate to,” signalling a departure from traditional notions of what a ballet dancer should look like. Mackay emphasised that plus-size performers are not just a possibility but an evolving reality, saying, “I think this is already happening.” He believes that this inclusivity will help to attract “new audiences” and enrich the performance landscape, allowing dancers of various body types and identities to share the stage.

However, the announcement has not been universally embraced. Social media erupted with mixed reactions, as critics expressed disbelief and concern over the practicalities of accommodating plus-size dancers within ballet’s physically demanding repertoire. Some comments ranged from dismissive to derogatory, arguing that increasing body diversity could inadvertently diminish the artistic integrity of performances. One critic bluntly stated, “Sorry, but I’m not paying to see that.” This skepticism reflects an ongoing tension in the decision to evolve traditional ballet norms, with fears that such changes might lead to a dilution of the art form.

Despite the backlash, supportive voices are rising in response. Many advocates for inclusivity, including the British actor George Keywood, have spoken out in favour of the Royal Ballet School’s direction. Keywood praised viral ballet sensation Lizzy Howell, noting her impressive skills and the joy she brings to performances regardless of her size. “We’re not encouraging obesity,” he clarifies, “but we’re encouraging her to be happy and be positive.” This sentiment aligns with a growing movement in the arts advocating for a broader definition of beauty and success, pushing against traditional standards that have long dominated the industry.

The backdrop to this transformative agenda is a troubling scandal that erupted earlier this year involving former student Ellen Elphick, who alleged severe body shaming during her training at the school. Elphick’s claims, which include derogatory remarks from teachers that contributed to her struggles with body image and eating disorders, have shed light on the darker side of ballet culture. The Royal Ballet School reached a financial settlement with her, but did not admit liability, instead asserting its commitment to ensuring student welfare moving forward. This case, significant in its implications, underscores the pressing need for reform within an industry grappling with severe psychological and emotional issues tied to body image.

Elphick’s experience resonates with many dancers who have suffered in similar toxic environments, marked by bullying and body negativity. Investigative reports point to a pervasive culture across elite ballet institutions that often prioritises aesthetic ideals over the mental health of its students, awakening calls for systemic change. The initiatives spearheaded by the Royal Ballet School, therefore, are not merely about inclusivity; they are also part of a larger response to these ongoing challenges within the dance community.

As the Royal Ballet School strides cautiously into this new chapter, it is clear that the conversation around inclusivity in ballet is far from settled. While the initiative aims to create a more holistic and representative ballet scene, it must navigate the complex landscape of historical expectations and the very real implications for aspiring dancers. Whether this shift will foster a more accepting and diverse environment remains a question that will unfold in the coming years, as both audiences and dancers weigh the merits and challenges of a changing art form.

Reference Map:

Source: Noah Wire Services