The topic of prostitution remains a deeply controversial issue in Scotland, with current legislative proposals stirring significant debate. Ash Regan, a Member of the Scottish Parliament (MSP), has openly challenged her colleagues to confront the realities of prostitution, stating, “Prostitution is something that a lot of politicians do not want to engage with. They are more than happy for this to be in the shadows.” This assertion is timely, particularly given her proposed Prostitution (Offences and Support) (Scotland) Bill, which seeks to criminalise the purchase of sex while decriminalising the selling of sexual services.

At present, while paying for sex is not illegal in Scotland, related activities such as operating a brothel or soliciting in public are criminal offences. Regan argues that her bill, inspired by the Nordic model implemented in countries like Sweden and Norway, aims to significantly reduce sex trafficking and enhance the safety of women involved in prostitution. Speaking to The Herald, she said, “The data that we have shows that in Sweden, prostitution has reduced to a very low level… sex trafficking is almost non-existent in Sweden.” Her aim is ambitious: to create a legislative framework that supports women in exiting prostitution and to ensure the accountability of those who seek to exploit them.

Despite her intentions, Regan faces substantial opposition. Critics, including advocacy groups like Scotland for Decrim, believe that her proposals neglect the underlying economic factors that drive individuals into sex work. Laura Baillie, the group’s political officer, pointed out, “Prostitution has been around because of the economic exploitation of women. If we really want to combat that, what we want to see are better anti-poverty measures.” The division within Scottish society regarding how best to address prostitution is evident, as polls indicate that nearly half of Scots favour the legalisation of paid sex, viewing it as a legitimate occupation.

The complexity of this issue is further highlighted by contrasting narratives surrounding the safety and welfare of individuals involved in sex work. Proponents of the Nordic model claim that criminalising the purchase of sex increases the safety of sex workers by reducing demand. However, evidence from places like Northern Ireland shows that reported assaults against sex workers increased by 225% after similar laws were introduced. These contradictions fuel ongoing debates over policy efficacy and the real-life implications for those within the industry.

Moreover, the issue of expunging past convictions for those involved in prostitution has become a focal point. Supporters of Regan’s bill contend that such measures are essential for helping individuals rebuild their lives and find employment, while groups like Christian Concern argue against pardoning past offences, advocating for continued deterrents against sex work.

Amidst these discussions, it’s important to consider the voices of those directly affected. Fiona Broadfoot, a former sex worker, shared her harrowing experiences at the launch of Regan’s bill, emphasising the trauma that often accompanies involvement in the industry. Although speaking passionately in favour of support mechanisms for vulnerable individuals, Broadfoot also resonates with a broader concern for safety and public perception.

Despite varied opinion within the Parliament, with several MSPs from the SNP and Labour backing Regan’s proposals, opposition remains firm from parties like the Greens and the Liberal Democrats, who advocate for full decriminalisation. The Greens specifically warn that Regan’s approach could lead to an underground system, compromising the safety of sex workers.

With a significant portion of the Scottish public seemingly favouring decriminalisation, it raises the question of whether lawmakers are aligning with societal views or leaning into a more traditionally punitive approach. Regan herself acknowledges the tight timeline for her bill, expressing hope for increased support as discussions unfold within Parliament. “I will admit, the time frames are tight… but I am confident it can be done,” she asserted.

In a landscape marked by shifting attitudes and entrenched beliefs about both the moral and legal frameworks surrounding prostitution, Scotland stands at a crossroads. The ongoing discussions around Regan’s proposals, and the nuanced views on prostitution and sex work, underscore a complex interplay of social, economic, and ethical dimensions that will shape the future of sexual autonomy and safety in Scotland.

Reference Map:

Source: Noah Wire Services