In the quiet town of Tullamore, County Offaly, a mother’s experience with a seemingly perfect nanny turned into a chilling tale of deceit. Layla, a mother of three, had hired Samantha Cookes—who masqueraded under the alias Lucy Hart—in 2015, believing her to be a nurturing caregiver akin to Mary Poppins. However, beneath the façade lay a web of lies that would leave Layla questioning the safety of her children and the trust she placed in a stranger.

Cookes presented herself as an award-winning writer and an expert in dealing with autism, while also claiming to suffer from a terminal illness. In reality, her history was marked by multiple aliases and a criminal past that involved deception and theft. Unbeknownst to Layla, Cookes had used at least six identities, including Carrie Jade Williams, and had recently served time for fraud in England. Such revelations are now being explored in a poignant two-part documentary series titled “Bad Nanny,” produced by BBC Northern Ireland and RTÉ, which delves into the lives of Cookes’ victims.

Initially, Layla seemed to form a strong bond with Cookes, a shared background as English expatriates in Ireland leading her to feel a sense of kinship. Yet, these initial months of harmony gave way to unease as Cookes started providing excuses for not allowing the family to visit the new home they were meant to move into. Each excuse only exacerbated Layla’s growing sense of distrust. After a series of deceptive behaviours, including simulating a health incident that prevented her from showing the new property, Cookes abruptly disappeared, citing a writers’ retreat.

Her departure left behind an ominous note that read, “I stand shoulder to shoulder with the coroner that I did not murder my daughter,” which prompted Layla to reconsider the motives and the true nature of the woman she had let into her home. This chilling discovery ignited fears for her children’s safety, considering the unsettling undertones of Cookes’ past, including the tragic loss of her first child, Martha, who died in suspicious circumstances just before adoption.

Beyond Layla’s story, many others have come forward detailing harrowing encounters with Cookes. For instance, Hillery Geelan, a mother seeking help for her autistic son, was similarly manipulated by Cookes, who was operating under yet another alias, Lucy Fitzwilliams. Geelan recounted how Lucy convinced her to trust her as a therapist while simultaneously soliciting money for a fictitious women’s refuge and a fake trip to Lapland.

Cookes’ methods were further exposed when another victim, Lynn McDonald, noted that while she had initially felt safe entrusting her daughter Ellie to Cookes, her worries escalated when she realised the extent of deception. Lynn explained how this stranger was attempting to gain legal guardianship of her daughter to take her out of the country, prompting acute concern for Ellie’s safety.

In an ironic twist, it was Cookes’ own actions that eventually led to her downfall. After a series of fraudulent claims, the authorities began to unravel her elaborate schemes. Cookes was eventually arrested and sentenced to three years in prison for defrauding the Irish government of over €60,000 through deceitful claims, including bogus disability allowances. Judge Ronan Munro criticised her for cynically exploiting human kindness and deceiving public welfare systems, calling her actions a “carefully orchestrated” plan to extract money.

Now, with the documentary bringing her story to light, if there’s one lesson to be drawn from Samantha Cookes’ deceitful narrative, it’s the stark reminder of the need for vigilance and verification, particularly when it concerns trust placed in caregivers. The emotional scars left on her victims remain, with many grappling with feelings of betrayal and fear, as well as the unsettling realisation that the person they trusted to care for their children was a stranger masquerading behind a carefully constructed veneer.

Ultimately, this tragic saga raises broader questions about the vetting processes for caregivers and the emotional toll that such betrayals can inflict on families. The experiences of Layla and others serve as a cautionary tale, emphasising the importance of thorough background checks and maintaining a degree of scepticism when engaging with individuals claiming to offer assistance in our lives.

Reference Map

Source: Noah Wire Services