Voters in Scotland are preparing to head to the polls on June 5, following the recent death of SNP MSP Christina McKelvie, marking a crucial by-election that has sparked intense rivalry among parties. This contest is perceived as a closely contested race primarily between the SNP and Reform UK, while Labour lags behind in third place. Nigel Farage, leader of Reform UK, has expressed buoyant confidence in his party’s chances, declaring that they are poised to succeed in Holyrood. His assertions have, however, been met with scepticism from his opponents, who are keen to dissuade voters from supporting Reform UK.

Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar has not shied away from confrontational rhetoric, recently characterising Farage’s campaign efforts as little more than a “circus.” Speaking to The Herald, Sarwar remarked, “The clown is coming to the circus,” implying that while Farage may attract attention, the issues confronting local communities require substantial, actionable change rather than populist spectacle. Sarwar’s sentiments highlight a growing frustration within Labour about the potential impact of Reform UK’s messaging, which some see as pandering to discontent without offering genuine solutions.

The back-and-forth between Sarwar and Farage is emblematic of a deeper struggle within Scottish politics, with Labour’s by-election candidate, Davy Russell, asserting that many voters are more focused on genuine representation than on the provocative tactics employed by Reform. He maintained that while disillusionment is palpable, most constituents are disinclined toward the quick fixes articulated by Farage and his party, rejecting narratives laden with divisive undertones.

Adding to the charged atmosphere, Reform’s candidate Ross Lambie has faced backlash over a video featuring Sarwar, which critics have denounced as racially provocative. The video, which manipulated Sarwar’s words to suggest an undue prioritisation of the Pakistani community, prompted denunciations from both Labour and the SNP as racially insensitive. Such actions raise questions about the integrity of campaigning tactics in an already divisive political landscape.

Concerns regarding economic policy have also come to the fore, particularly in relation to Farage’s stance on energy jobs in Scotland. Stephen Flynn, SNP’s leader in Westminster, argued that Farage’s disregard for climate-oriented initiatives, such as the North East Acorn project, poses severe risks to the employment landscape in the North East. Flynn labelled Farage’s claims of cost-savings from abandoning environmentally sustainable strategies as speculative and harmful, warning that such policies could jeopardise jobs in both the present and future energy sectors. Flynn stressed the necessity of developing skills and investments that would secure Scotland’s economy for years to come while maintaining critical energy jobs.

In a bid to counter Sarwar’s claims and to reposition Reform UK, a spokesperson from the party suggested that the SNP’s policies have obstructed economic growth in Scotland, illustrating their belief that proper approaches to oil and gas exploration could contribute positively to job creation. The spokesperson’s comments reflect a contentious debate over energy policies, where both parties vie for the trust of an electorate keen on securing employment while grappling with pressing environmental commitments.

As the by-election looms closer, the dynamics of this electoral battle reveal a backdrop of contrasting visions for Scotland’s future. The increasing visibility of Reform UK, although still limited compared to its success in England—with only about 7% of votes in Scotland during previous elections—indicates a burgeoning, albeit contentious, presence in Scottish politics. The party’s performance and Farage’s tactics going forward will likely influence not just the by-election outcome but set the tone for the 2026 Holyrood elections as well.

With so much at stake, the outcome of the by-election could serve as a litmus test for wider political sentiments in Scotland, revealing whether discontent with the current government is leading voters toward Reform UK or if traditional parties will maintain their stronghold in Scottish politics.

Reference Map:

Source: Noah Wire Services