Andrew Neil has critically assessed the introduction of Scotland’s new hate crime legislation, following nearly 4,000 complaints being filed with Police Scotland within the first 48 hours of the law’s enactment. Reflecting on whether Scotland possesses deep-seated hate issues or if the law encourages trivial reports, Neil pointed out the significant number of complaints against First Minister Humza Yousaf, overshadowing even those against JK Rowling. Concerns have risen over how incidents are classified, particularly regarding “non-crime hate incidents,” and the potential challenges to free speech. Critics worry about the ease with which the legislation might be misused for vexatious complaints. Despite backlash, Yousaf firmly supports the law, aiming to tackle the purported increase in hate crimes, while Neil criticizes the coalition government’s management of the law’s implementation.

In a separate matter, First Minister Yousaf is keen for a quick wrap-up of the ongoing police inquiry into the SNP’s finances, dubbed Operation Branchform. This investigation began in July 2021, focusing on allegations of misuse involving £600,000 intended for Scottish independence campaigning. The scrutiny followed the arrest of Peter Murrell, the SNP’s former chief executive and husband of ex-First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, later extending to other party members. Yousaf has stated the importance of Police Scotland completing a detailed investigation without external intervention, emphasizing the SNP’s anticipation of the inquiry’s conclusion. Meanwhile, police remain tight-lipped, with past comments acknowledging the complexity of financial probes but promising a timely resolution. The investigation continues to place the SNP under significant examination regarding its financial handling.