The selection of Davy Russell as the Scottish Labour candidate for the upcoming Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election has sparked significant criticism within the party. Some insiders have disparagingly branded him a “donkey” due to his apparent reluctance to engage with media opportunities that could bolster his campaign. As the by-election looms, triggered by the untimely passing of SNP MSP Christina McKelvie, the internal strife within Labour raises questions about its strategy and readiness to confront both the SNP and the emerging challenge from Reform UK.

Russell, a former business associate of Rangers boss Barry Ferguson, has been publicly supported by Labour’s leadership. A spokesperson stated that he is “standing up for his community and working tirelessly” to ensure a Labour victory. However, party sources have expressed discontent, suggesting that his absence from pivotal broadcasting opportunities demonstrates a lack of confidence and strategy. One senior figure articulated a concern that Russell’s failure to engage effectively with the media could lead Labour to a disappointing third place in the election, a consideration underscored by the growing momentum of Reform UK.

This critical situation has not gone unnoticed by political opponents. SNP’s candidate, Katy Loudon, remarked on Labour’s apparent invisibility in the campaign and asserted that only the SNP has been willing to take a stand against figures like Nigel Farage. The criticism was echoed by former Labour MSP Neil Findlay, who lamented Russell’s “Trappist monk approach” to campaigning. He emphasized that effective communication with voters is essential in a high-profile by-election, highlighting the risks of Labour falling behind both the SNP and rival parties.

Compounding Labour’s woes is the strategic backdrop of the by-election itself. John Swinney, Scotland’s First Minister, seized the opportunity to frame this election as a potential wake-up call for Labour, urging the party to reflect candidly on its performance and policies. Such sentiments indicate a wider concern about Labour’s standing in Scottish politics, particularly amidst a landscape where the SNP remains a dominant force but must be vigilant against the rising tide of Reform UK, which seeks to capitalise on Labour’s internal issues.

Despite the challenges, Russell has defended his candidacy by focusing on grassroots campaigning, stating his preference for “chapping doors” and directly engaging with constituents rather than participating in televised debates. This grass-roots approach, however, could be undermining his visibility and, by extension, Labour’s competitiveness in the race. The decision to forego the media spotlight during a critical campaign phase, such as the debate hosted by STV, has raised eyebrows and prompted further criticism from within the party.

As Labour heads toward the polls on June 5th, the stakes are high not only for Russell’s candidacy but for the party’s future in Scotland. The party’s performance in this by-election could signal a broader reckoning, igniting discussions about its relevance and appeal in a rapidly evolving political landscape. Anas Sarwar, the Scottish Labour leader, has stated that the outcome could set the stage for a substantial challenge to SNP dominance, viewing the by-election as a pivotal moment for the party.

With both internal and external pressures mounting, the narrative of this campaign will be closely watched, as it could redefine the dynamics of Scottish politics and the role of Labour therein.

Reference Map:

Source: Noah Wire Services